Do we need another Greece?

The tent-dwellers’ revolt calls for the enforcement of ‘the will of the people’ (like all autocrats).

It refuses to rely on Democracy.

Filed under:

financial markets • fundamentals • public policy • reform • limiting government • welfare • world affairs

Do we want a little anarchy? If so, let us don our red Lacoste shirts (imprinted with hammers and sickles), gather at Rabin Square and sing “The Internationale” (the anthem of the mass murderers who just wanted to make life better and more just) like the young tent-dwelling protesters did.

Let us hoarsely scream, “The people demand social justice!” and “Let the revolution destroy privatization!” and call for a return to benevolent Socialism, to the good old Mapai days when everybody except for those holding the red party card were equally poor, and solidarity reigned supreme (or so we are told).

Let us harken to the lovely young ladies, the fresh plantings of the New Israel Fund; pay attention to what terrible rage animates their mission. Let us search for meaning in their worn-out clichés, and try to forgive their inability to articulate what they really want.

Let us marvel at a young generation that repeats like parrots the stale mantras of their aging Marxist professors, who dominate social studies and humanity departments in all our universities. Let us bemoan the fact that generations of exceptionally talented young people are incapable of coming up with one fresh idea, one that is not a repetition of recycled leftist slogans.

Let us shed a tear that a young and vital generation can only become fired up by what it negates, what it hates, what it despises; that it cannot suggest one solution to any social problem other than let the government pour more money into it, or let it offer us a big teat from which to nurse because it is so hard to grow up and shape our own destiny.

Let us observe sadly the Woodstock- style celebration, the beating of darbukas past midnight, the smoking of sweet weeds, the politicking and the intrigues – who should dominate the stage, who will best inflame anger and frustration, who will best silence the voices of dissent that denote that the vociferous minority does not really represent a majority in this revolt; that the majority is behind the less photogenic but more serious cottage cheese revolt people, despite the fact that they have no buddies in the media to blow their horn.

The tent-dwellers’ revolt calls for the enforcement of “the will of the people” (like all autocrats). It refuses to rely simply on democracy, on elections every four years.

The tent-dwellers’ screaming minority wants the masses to follow the messages formulated by the New Israel Fund, to understand that the struggle is not about the high cost of living and of housing, but about the lack of “social justice” and about the occupation that is the mother of all evil.

They want to impress on us – as the New Israel Fund keeps reiterating – that “social justice” will not come to Israel, that our coveted socialist state of all its citizens (that will replace the quaint notion of a Jewish state) will not happen before we first “make peace” with the gangs of terrorists and thieves in Ramallah known as the Palestinian Authority. They care not if in the process we help build another jihadist state that robs its citizens, as in Gaza, of any human right.

They care not if we help the gangsters imported by us from Tunisia to make the local population dirt-poor and miserable. Vive la liberte! To achieve their obsession with building another criminal Arab state, the leaders of the tent dwellers’ protest want to topple Binyamin Netanyahu’s government.

What better opportunity to undermine it than to exploit the true misery of hundreds of thousands of Israeli families that cannot make ends meet? So on with the fiery demonstrations.

They hope they can succeed in shifting the justified rage so many Israelis feel against their rapacious economic system, against the bureaucrats and oligarchs that exploit them so badly, and direct it against Netanyahu to serve their pro-PLO agenda. And yes, a little chaos like in Athens could help. They tried it at the mass demonstrations. It did not catch on yet.

Let us be clear. The people of Israel do suffer under our dysfunctional economic system. Our politicians are the ones who put this system in place and who keep maintaining it for their own benefit and for the bureaucrats, the oligarchs, the monopoly unions and others with privileged access to power. But if there was one person who made an effort to change this, it is Netanyahu. He met, and still meets, huge resistance from those who benefit from our rotten system. Still, he did manage, against all odds, to occasionally prevail, paying a heavy political cost.

We have now in Israel an historic opportunity for those who, like Netanyahu, wish to make real changes but lacked the political support to overcome the resistance of those opposing change. It is not clear yet whether he will win the day, whether he believes that he can get a strong enough backing to rise to the occasion. Let us pray he does.

More recent commentary

The Jerusalem Post
30 Jun ’15

PJ Media
20 Jun ’15

The Jerusalem Post
7 Jun ’14

Israel Hayom
15 May ’14

Israel Hayom
23 Feb ’14

The Jerusalem Post
9 Jan ’14

The Jerusalem Post
11 Jul ’13

The Weekly Standard
7 Jun ’13

The Weekly Standard
22 Apr ’13

Israel Hayom
2 Jan ’13

The Jerusalem Post
7 Dec ’12

Israel Hayom
8 Nov ’12

The Financial Times
21 Jun ’12

Israel Hayom
6 Jun ’12

The Jerusalem Post
7 May ’12

The Wall Street Journal
3 May ’12

Middle East Quarterly
30 Mar ’12

The Jerusalem Post
17 Feb ’12

The Jerusalem Post
25 Oct ’11

The Jerusalem Post
20 Jul ’11

The Jerusalem Post
28 Jun ’11

The New Republic
19 May ’11

The Jerusalem Post
15 Mar ’11

The Jerusalem Post
7 Feb ’11

The Jerusalem Post
22 Jan ’11

The Jerusalem Post
1 Dec ’10

The Jerusalem Post
17 Oct ’10

The Wall Street Journal
8 Oct ’10

The Jerusalem Post
4 Oct ’10

The Jerusalem Post
19 Aug ’10

The Jerusalem Post
13 Jul ’10

The Jerusalem Post
30 May ’10

The Wall Street Journal
18 May ’10

The Jerusalem Post
10 Feb ’10

The Jerusalem Post
10 Jan ’10

The Jerusalem Post
14 Oct ’09

The Jerusalem Post
22 Sep ’09